A
restricted earth fault protection (REF) and an
unrestricted earth fault protection (UEF) scheme are both used to detect earth faults (short circuits or faults to the ground) in electrical systems, but they differ in their scope and how they operate.
1. Restricted Earth Fault Protection (REF):
- Scope of Protection: The restricted earth fault protection is designed to detect faults only within a specific section of the system, typically the zone between the transformer and the breaker.
- Working Principle: REF protection uses differential current to detect faults. It compares the current entering and leaving a specific part of the system (like the transformer or generator). Under normal conditions, the sum of the currents entering and leaving the protected zone should be zero. If there is an earth fault inside the protected zone, the current will be unbalanced, triggering the protection.
- Sensitivity: REF protection is highly sensitive and can detect even small fault currents. It's mainly used for protection against faults on the star-point (neutral) of transformers and generators, particularly when there's a low impedance fault.
- Advantages: REF provides selective protection, meaning it will only trip the breaker for faults in the protected zone, preventing unnecessary trips in other parts of the system.
2. Unrestricted Earth Fault Protection (UEF):
- Scope of Protection: Unrestricted earth fault protection provides a broader range of protection, covering the entire system and detecting earth faults anywhere within the network.
- Working Principle: UEF protection detects faults by measuring the earth fault current in the system. It does not require a comparison between input and output currents, as it simply monitors the total fault current flowing to ground. It can detect faults that occur anywhere in the electrical network, not just in a limited zone.
- Sensitivity: UEF protection is typically less sensitive than REF, as it's designed to protect larger parts of the system. It may not detect smaller faults as quickly as REF does.
- Advantages: UEF protection is useful for system-wide protection and can protect against faults in large networks, but it may result in a trip if a fault occurs in areas outside the critical zone.
Key Differences:
| Feature | Restricted Earth Fault (REF) | Unrestricted Earth Fault (UEF) |
|---------|------------------------------|--------------------------------|
|
Scope | Protects a specific zone (e.g., transformer) | Protects the entire system |
|
Working Principle | Uses differential current (in-zone comparison) | Measures the total fault current to ground |
|
Sensitivity | Highly sensitive to small faults | Less sensitive compared to REF |
|
Protection Type | Selective protection for a particular section | General protection for the entire network |
|
Application | Primarily used for transformer/generator protection | Used for overall system protection |
In summary,
REF protection is more precise and sensitive, focusing on faults in a specific area, while
UEF protection is broader, offering general protection across the whole system.